Heavenly Homemade Sugar Free Oreo Cookies

Detailed Directions (With Pictures)

*Please note there is a printable recipe card at the end*

The first step to every great recipe is preparation, let’s start by setting out all of our needed ingredients. You wouldn’t want to get half way through this sweet little adventure and realize you are missing a key ingredient!

cookies sugar free oreo

Next, in a separate bowl, we are going to combine out dry ingredient mixture together. That will be flour, salt, and coco powder.

combine dry ingredients

In a large mixing bowl we will now cream together our erythritol, coconut, sugar, and butter.

 erythritol, coconut, sugar, and butter combining them together
sugar mixing in
erythritol adding

Once that is all nicely combined, we will add in the vanilla and egg, then mix those in smoothly.

combined ingredients in a bowl
cocoa being added
vanilla being added
butter being added

We should now have all of our wet ingredients combined in a large mixing bowl, fully combined all together.

That means its time to add in the dry ingredient mixture. One cup at a time while mixing on low. Wait until each cup of flour is completely combined before adding the next. Repeat this until all the dry ingredients have been added in.

egg being added
dry ingredients being added

Add this point our batter should looking like this chocolaty goodness here.

dough for cookies

Next, we will be traying our cookies up, onto parchment paper lined cookie sheets.

Roll out tablespoon sized balls, and place them on the cookie sheets.

balls of cookie dough

Then flatten them! You can use the palm of your hand or the back of a spoon.

flattering cookie dough

Fire those baby cakes into your preheated oven, bake at 350 D for 8-12 min. Keep an eye on them in the last few minutes to make sure they don’t overcook. if the tops split it makes for a difficult topper to our tasty Oreos.

cookie parts combined into oreos

Let them completely cool before filing them with icing! We cannot stress this enough… If you try icing while they are still warm you will battle melting icing and tops sliding right off the cookie. After all that work, trust us when we say, just wait the extra few minutes.

completed sugar free oreos


If you would like to print out this recipe or save for latter use, hit the print button below!